OpenAI Seeks Dismissal of Tumbler Ridge Shooting Lawsuits

OpenAI and its CEO, Sam Altman, are urging a U.S. federal judge in California to dismiss 41 lawsuits tied to the Tumbler Ridge school shooting. They argue that conversations with AI chatbots are protected by the First Amendment and that the company had no legal duty to alert law enforcement about potential violence. In their latest motion, OpenAI and Altman contend that the plaintiffs failed to establish a direct link between ChatGPT’s responses and the tragic events, emphasizing that none of Van Rootselaar’s 10,000 messages mentioned the school specifically.
The lawsuits, filed by victims’ families, survivors, the B.C. government, and the local school district, claim OpenAI should have warned police after its safety system flagged Jesse Van Rootselaar’s ChatGPT account for discussions about gun violence. Despite shutting down her first account in June 2025, OpenAI did not notify authorities. On February 10, Van Rootselaar killed eight people, including six at Tumbler Ridge Secondary School, before taking her own life. Plaintiffs highlight that two OpenAI employees who reviewed the account believed Van Rootselaar posed a credible threat and recommended contacting Canadian authorities, though OpenAI maintains the threat did not meet its threshold for police notification.
Read Also: Cyberattacks Disrupt Canadian Law Firms via Social Engineering Scams
OpenAI’s Defense: First Amendment and No Duty to Warn
OpenAI contends that conversations with its chatbot should receive the same First Amendment protections as traditional media, such as books and video games. The company is also seeking to block the release of thousands of messages exchanged between Van Rootselaar and ChatGPT, arguing that disclosing them could compromise the RCMP’s investigation. In a Nov. 5 filing, OpenAI specifically requested to keep Van Rootselaar’s full ChatGPT history and account records private, including excerpts cited by the plaintiffs.
Legal Battles Over Jurisdiction and Evidence
Mark Stacey, whose wife was killed in the shooting, argues OpenAI had a legal responsibility to act on the reviewers’ warnings, drawing parallels to a California case involving psychotherapists’ duty to protect threatened individuals. In an October 29 court filing, Stacey pointed to this case, asserting that OpenAI had a similar duty because ChatGPT functioned in a therapist-like role for Van Rootselaar. OpenAI disputes this, claiming ChatGPT is a dynamic online service, not a defective product.
The company has also challenged the jurisdiction of the California court, arguing that B.C. is the more appropriate venue. Plaintiffs counter that nearly all account reviewers were based in California, as noted in a Nov. 5 filing, and that B.C.’s wrongful-death rules could limit families’ recovery to funeral expenses. The B.C. government and local school board have pushed back, arguing in a Nov. 16 filing that OpenAI’s request would keep more than 4,000 pages of over 29,000 messages out of public view, and suggested instead that the court redact sensitive material and make the rest public.
Read Also: Koho sues fraudsters over $5.2 million glitch
Privacy Concerns and Public Access to Records
OpenAI is pushing to keep Van Rootselaar’s ChatGPT history and account records sealed, claiming their release could compromise the RCMP’s investigation. They also noted that the RCMP has not taken a stance on whether the records should be sealed. Dow Jones, publisher of The Wall Street Journal, has separately requested the judge to make court records public. A hearing on this is set for December 17.
Aftermath and Policy Changes
Following the shooting, Canada’s AI Minister, Evan Solomon, summoned OpenAI’s safety team to Ottawa. The company pledged to revise its handling of violence threats and admitted it would have alerted police under new guidelines. B.C.’s privacy commissioner is investigating OpenAI’s handling of personal information, but the company has asked a B.C. court to halt the probe. OpenAI’s motion also revealed that Van Rootselaar’s ChatGPT usage dropped sharply from 30 messages daily to three in the months before the shooting, with none mentioning the school.